Melvadius
-
Posts
2,275 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Static Pages
News
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Downloads
Posts posted by Melvadius
-
-
The BBC are now carrying a copy of the video presentation as well.
So far as what the scrolls contain if those which have already been forced open by the techniques developed in the 18th and 19th centuries are anything to go by then there is liable to be a significant number of Epicurean texts so mainly philosophical in nature but I believe that a few other scrolls have been identified so possibly some plays and other material will be found as well.
Finds of smut may actually be fairly limited but there are several scholars who would dearly love for one of the 450 undamaged so totally unread scrolls to contain at least one of the lost nine books of lyric poetry written by Sappho.
-
1
-
-
Of more moment you need to provide evidence of which language there is a supposed correlation. If it is in the original Hebrew, Aramaic or Greek texts then there may be cause to consider there is a direct correlation between the two. If it is only in a particular set of English translations (but not all) then the only proof it provides is that the translators used the same alternative word order (in translation of ancient texts there are usually at least two or three possibilities) or more seriously the choices when considered against alternative meanings could show actual evidence of manipulation of the translations to make a more precise cross reference between both texts.
Even if you ignore the abundant literary evidence for Christianity pre-dating the Flavians IF you are claiming this as scientific evidence you need to provide full information on precisely which texts you are comparing (i.e. date of publication, edition, translator and publisher) otherwise it really is no better than any other hare brained Von Daniken type theory which at base is using manufactured evidence.
-
The press and those who have vested interests in denying it talk about 'Global warming' those who actually work in the field tend to talk more about 'climate change'.
A rise in global average temperatures at a simplistic level is seen by those who don't actually consider all the ramifications as a good thing but what it actually means is that our traditional weather patterns are changing globally.
It will not be a great advantage to have hotter winters if your growing season during the summer becomes unstable and the you get hit by more frequent sudden storms or heat waves, which kill your crops 3 times out of 4. Claimed hotter winters in the UK has only tended to mean more stormy weather without the benefit of an extended growing season since that is driven by the period of available sunlight NOT a degree or two increase in temperature.
Has anyone noticed how there has been an upsurge in tornado activity in the US grain belt.....?
-
If you really have to to make a 'modern' equivalent you would be better off considering a contubernium as organised in a similar way to a Napoleonic period navy mess as a group of eight men (not ten as stated earlier on) who would sleep and eat together and formed part of a larger unit (ie a contuberniuim formed part of a century). Obviously the comparison is incomplete since one would primarily operate on water and the other on land but I agree with Caldrail that trying to fit modern military units into Roman equivalents and vice versa is all too often illogical or is too period specific .
I particularly remember one of the translations of the Gallic wars which was written just after the second world war and since he was an ex-military man the translator went too far and talks about regiments, captains, majors and colonels rather than the correct Roman terminology. Read fifty years after WW2 when military service is only something a small number of people have on their resume it had lost all relevance to both the modern and historic periods.
-
1000ibs? That is probably incorrect information based on mistaken original research in 1910 by de Noettes. Try searching for 'Roman Traction Systems' on the web Weller provides evidence that at least 1 to 1.5 metric ton wagon loads were possible.
-
Although not as bad as the post I have just removed this post is now locked for the same reason as that one. Can we keep thing polite in future please folks md keep external links to material relevant to a sensible discussion of Roman related topics - not to vanity sites or interpretations of such
-
I would remind people that this website is to be used to discuss Roman history not to post multiple links to a personal vanity website especially when the posts are made simply as an excuse to post another link to such sites and do not add anything to what had previously been discussed.
I have just had to remove an extensive post since in effect due to the repeated superfluous inclusion of such links it had become spam.
-
Some of the issue we have is the general impression, mainly from Pompeii and Herculaneum the only places where complete wall decorations survive, of deep vibrant but somewhat garish colours.
It is only in the last few years that some scientific studies have been made on the pigments used in Roman paints with the realisation that those garish colour schemes may in be part down to the effects of the volcano with colour changes having occurred due to the intense heat of the eruption.
-
There are now more details of at least some of the coins (55 or so) on the Portable Antiquities Site here:
The interesting thing is that it looks like somebody conflated dates in the original reports so rather than referring to a coin dated 428 AD it may have been a mistranscribed reference to the fact that the Honorius coins in the Hoard were generally dated between 402 and 408 AD.
-
Congratulations Maty,
I'm only partially sorry that we weren't able to contribute more to the gestation of your new venture it was beginning to shape up as an interesting read. At least this way we get to read the finished product without being able to know 'precisely' what is going to happen next...
-
Doing a quick check the style seems to have spread with the initial advance of the Empire so there are examples is far apart of as Palestine and Gaul. Although not that many seem to have been excavated the indications are that it was slowly adapted to local conditions. One academic source on the web indicates that it only reached about half-way up Gaul and between the mid-1st century BC and AD the style changed to what became the more usual villa style(s) found in Britain and elsewhere.
In my view possibly it was a reaction to suit the different climate found in northern climes when you tend to be more concerned about getting rid of water than collecting it for domestic use.
-
Welcome to the site Optimus Princeps.
-
Welcome Number Six. I take it this is not a typo for the Classic Number 6:
'I will not make any deals with you. I've resigned. I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own. I resign.'
-
Humphrey, Oleson & Sherwood (2002) Greek and Roman Technology : A Sourcebook has a few references which may be of use since this provides translations of contemporary sources the 'vehicles' section (pg 428 - 433) and animal husbandry (p 129-131 especially).
-
Welcome to the site Korin,
This is because as a new poster all of your posts are moderated and some of the functionality of the site limited however once you have made a couple more posts which are accepted onto the site you will have passed the initial probationary period and be able to make the changes you are asking about as well as making posts without prior moderation.
-
Welcome to UNRV RonnyBoy - generalists have their place here just the same as specialists. Apart from anything else there are probably more generalists than specialists about anyway
-
I agree an interesting footnote in the annals of railway history.
There seems to be several different versions of the 'battle' which precise spin is put on it seems ot be highly dependent on which of the current reports of it are used as the basis of the story.
I found http://www.ampneycrucis.f9.co.uk/PARK/MickletonTunnel.htm'>this site which has a few of the various iterations but also a couple of useful maps of the area.
-
Abraham/Abraam "Ab=Father and Raam/Rome? ", does that name evoke "Father Rome" / Romulus.
Their is something very Roman about Judaism.
No it doesn't and no it isn't.
-
The Dead Sea Scholar, John Allegro , Did indeed verify that Yahweh, Zeus and Jove are the same in Origin, the 3 Deities are composed of Two Syllables , which is IA (ya, dialectally za), and U ( or W/V).
This would be the same John Allegro who wrote The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross?
An interesting viewpoint by all accounts when first written and still raising eyebrows today amongst most scholars.
The linkage between Roman and Greek mythology is well attested however the jury is still out on the other leg of your proposition.
-
According to some scholars Jove is pronounced yo-ve and pronounced by some as "ya-o-ve." (Jahovah), Identical to the
God of Judaism, So Hadrian dedicated the City to a Roman God which is pronounced the same way was the Jewish God.
<SNIP>
I believe this is Evidence of Deliberate rewriting of History.
I believe this is more likely evidence of extremely sloppy research on the part of any 'scholar' who promotes this fallacy:
This was recently discussed as Etymological Relationship between Latin "Iove" and Hebrew "Yahweh"? at the Ask
Metafilter site where one of the respondents pointed out that in their view it had already been definitively answered on the Ancient Near East mailing list by Aayko Eyma in 1998
http://ask.metafilter.com/14348/Etymological-Relationship-between-Latin-Iove-and-Hebrew-Yahweh
The Greek version of the Hebrew divine name has little relationship to Jove (iovis). The similarity appeared much later, after the questionable transliteration of Yahweh as "Jehovah."
A quick Google and a bit of sifting is all it took to find out the topic comes up regularly on the Ancient Near East mailing list. Find "Aayko Eyma" on this page (April 9, 1998); his post gets referenced on the list later as relatively definitive:
Perhaps your question was invoked by the late medieval form Jehova? - which however is based on wrong vocalisation. Note that the V in that form stems from Latin, expressing the W sound, not our modern V sound, and the J expressing the Y sound, not the modern English J. The Hebrew divine name YHWH, so with W, sounded like Yahweh. In Greek the name was transliterated _iaoue_ (Clement of Alexandria) or even _iabe_ (Theodoret); as in Greek, 'ou' or 'b' came closest to w, and they could not render the Hebrew H in the middle of words either. The short or poetic form of YHWH was Yahu, in Greek lettering transliterated as _iaO_.
So any resemblance between Yahweh/Yahu and Jove (iovis) is not really big.
-
The article quite clearly states:
Today, the meaning of the designs in this particular spot is a mystery, though patches of newly cleaned plaster on other parts of the wall show a palm frond in red (a symbol of victory) and the letters "VIND," which may be part of the word vindicatio, or vengeance
-
I suppose this means that the place we are looking for is now in Northern Italy and lies either inland on the Via Cassia or nearer the coast on the Via Amelia/ Amelia Scauri.
I would guess that we are probably looking at the northern end so guess somewhere between Pisa and Genoa on the Via Amelia Scauri. :unsure:/>
-
Some good archaeology even if probably not what I would term the 'greatest archaeological story of the year' as some reports would have it - simply very good research and a lot of luck since the remains had survived Victorian building work. I tend to reserve that term for discoveries where archaeologists are making finds working with a lot less information.
Personally I liked the reports that the archaeologists found Richard III by following a hunch
-
I suppose that size of said escapees may also be a consideration - 14,999 fingerlings and one big one - gun optional extra buy more 'flit' instead or at least take big stick. 15,000 big ones move permanently away from river
Words emerge from ancient scrolls charred during eruption of Vesuvius
in Archaeological News: Rome
Posted
It's been a while but life has calmed down a bit now so hopefully I will be able to participate fully again once I sort out the changes to the sites platform