Jump to content
UNRV Ancient Roman Empire Forums

Hitoriki Batosai

Plebes
  • Posts

    11
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Hitoriki Batosai

  1. It could work only if the men were extemily skilled and could hold the position throught a battle while taking some casualtys.

    Another thing. the spears would have to be the 8 foot long hoplite spears not the 18 foot levy men spears. If they were 18 feet long the romans could not carry thier shields as well and they would cover such little land in one days time.

     

     

    P.S. I was wondering if cavery hit hop lites or even elephaunts do you think the spear could posibly snap in two?

  2. I just recently picked up a book on Caesar which I will now start reading. Its by Christian Meier translated from German into English. Ill give a review as soon as I can after.

     

     

    on a scale of 1 to 10 how good is is this book by Christian Meier?

  3. Lets try a new one, man.

    Before Marius reforms:

    Your in egypt on the east side of the nile, fighting the pharoh's strongest and largest army on the west side of the nile, they are composed of entierly veterans.

    You are the romans with 2 legions,50 velites, around 200 cavalry, and a 100 mercenary horse archers from parthia.

    The enemy consists of 20,000 spear men, 400 chariots, 100 archers, and 100 camal riders.

    Your men ar tired of walking and are ready to bed down for the night when the egyptians attack.

     

     

     

     

    WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

  4. Try this one.

     

    Your in Germanic lands and they have sent a detatchement of 80,000 men! Your stuck until your reenforcements come and have you only 20,000 men. They have twice as much cavalry, and are hungry for Roman blood. Your siege equipment is firing down on the enemy and your archers do too. Their axeman run into your legions, and you realize their cavalry is slamming into yours. Your now in a full attack as your reenforcements arrive. The army will be doomed if you don't get your fresh troops to them, and you must be diligent ad hurry. How would you come across in an effective attack to overrun the enemy?

     

     

     

    Let the 20,000 men die for roman honor and leave the germans tired and have huge casultys because of roman strength.

    The germans dont know of the reniforments comig so wait until night and ambush them using roman archers to attack with a quick barrage of arrows then liht the arrows a blaze, then they would know were you are and attack with no armour. have your velites and legions throuh their pila and masacre them. after that send every man in for a full on charge to wipe them out.

  5. Hi, I'm new here. Let's try another scenario.

     

    It is a couple years after the defeat of Hannibal and are commanding 2 legions, 1 is made up of veterans from the punic war and the other is made up of raw recruits. You are in Macedonia, as the Macedonians had helped Carthage, and you are chasing the macedonian army. Finally you have drawn them to battle, but the outnumber you 2 to 1. They have set up on a hill with a heavy forest to your left, and a light one to the right. The hill is covered with grass. It is about mid-day. You have been trying to get them to battle, and now they are ready. they cavalry outnumbers yours 3 to 1. What will you do?

     

    Have fun

     

    The macidoinan cavelry is supurb a calvery fight is out of the question espacilly if they out number you 3-1. I would head to the dense forest were the phalanx would have a hard time manovering and thus fall victom to a charge of vetran legonares and raw recruts. With the phalanx in dire need of help the enemy calvery would come to there aid thats were you have your calvery comes and attacks them from the side (as a decoy). When they are close but the legonares still have there pila to throw. So before their calvery get there you hit them witha barrage of pila scaring the horses and possibly causing a stamped and then hit the phalanx hard in the back with your cavery. then when the phalanx are destroded kill off the calvery with pilum and cavery.

  6. Form line of battle and drive straight at 'em. Not very elaborate but it worked for the Romans very well...

     

    I might wait till later in the day to avoid the disadvantage of the sun in my troops face but not if the enemy looked like withdrawing, or indeed if they looked like doing anything other than standing still.

     

     

     

    yes but forming a line of battle could encurage the enemy to fight harder, or you could have the legions through tere pilums and spread panik through out the enemy.

×
×
  • Create New...