Jump to content
UNRV Ancient Roman Empire Forums
  • entries
    82
  • comments
    315
  • views
    61,969

Hemlock and Tobacco


Pertinax

2,962 views

Hemlock was the poison used to execute Socrates for corrupting youth and neglecting the Gods...it contains two poisonous alkaloids coniine and coniceine (the plant is named Conium maculatum). These block the transmission of nerve impulses which cause death by failure of respiration (ie: one ceases to try to breathe).

The actual execution (as described by Plato) has the executioner examining the victims legs and feet , pressing them to see if the sensation is lost in these extremities , the numbness that Socrates felt traveled slowly up his body (which became cold to touch) and as it made toward his heart he expired.

 

http://www.unrv.com/forum/index.php?act=mo...=si&img=854

 

A similar plant is Water Hemlock which contains cicutoxin (the plant is Cicuta maculatum which I have seen growing abundantly near Mediobogdum) , the root resembles a turnip and if partly ingested is fatal in at least 30 percent of cases.The action is one of violent seizures affecting the spine and brain.

 

A further related toxin is nicotine from tobacco.This is very similar to coniine and it is the essential addictive element that draws smokers.In sensory terms the initial ingestion causes euphoria and nerve stimulation, thence desensitisation and depression.The leaves were originally "tobago" possibly first found by Columbus and brought by Raleigh from America to England.Nicotine is from the name Jean Nicot de Villemain an explore who sent seeds of the plant back to Europe in the 16th C.Nicotine is very toxic and can be used as a potent insecticide , indeed two drops of the pure substance dropped on to a small mammals tongue (a dog for example ) will kill outright.So an addiction to nicotine is actually related to the ingestion of the Athenian state poison .

 

Of course the Roman soldier in Africa and the Syrian provinces might well have known this plant as anaesthesia and recreational adjunct:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimsonweed

 

 

 

ref Timbrell "The Poison Paradox".

19 Comments


Recommended Comments

We have plenty of plants that look like the hemlock you have pictured--they grow abundantly in California. But, while most do call it 'hemlock', it has a very licorice scent--perhaps is there a type of fennel which looks like hemlock? Or does hemlock smell similar to anise/fennel?

Link to comment

The umbelliferae are a very large group ( thats an understatement -vast), ive spent a long time annotating and photographing them. Within that group we have angelica, fennel, wild parsley and caraway( which is somewhat poisonous if not used correctly) that are culinary spices ; we also have wild carrot, pignut and giant hogweed that vary from decorative to intrusive and poisinous to livestock. We have Yarrow and elderberry great healing herbs.Then we have hemlock. They look similar- there are tell tale signs to discriminate , the worst of them (Hemlock and Oenanthe) have either purple stems or blotched stems , and smell bad when broken. I am going to publish a small paper on identification of the species, with a photographic guide , early versions will be beta tested on my msn blog.

Cornell have this useful resource for a particular locality:

http://images.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=h...ficial%26sa%3DG

take a good look at the Water Hemlock stem colour.

I will put some shots up on msn soon and pm you -leaf shape, inflorescence shape and smell all help, but if in doubt , dont eat em!

Link to comment

Hemlock was said to be a European plant, but can a plant in Greece grow in places with different climates? Greece has a hot and humid climate while Britain's and Scandanavias has an ice climate, would this impact where it is grown in Europe?

 

Was it grown anywhere else in the world?

Link to comment
I am going to publish a small paper on identification of the species, with a photographic guide , early versions will be beta tested on my msn blog.

Cornell have this useful resource for a particular locality:

http://images.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=h...ficial%26sa%3DG

take a good look at the Water Hemlock stem colour.

I will put some shots up on msn soon and pm you -leaf shape, inflorescence shape and smell all help, but if in doubt , dont eat em!

 

Wonderful, Pertinax...I've been curious about the flora that grow locally, and the whole "If you don't know, don't touch/taste!" mentality keeps me from going near what I suspect to truly be hemlock. Even if it is wild fennel...I'd rather get mine from the market ;)

Link to comment

The range of Hemlock is the whole of Europe and Northern Asia , as ive mentioned previously , the closer to the Nile -the stronger the active principle of the plant. So yes we can have the same plant in Britain and Greece, and as one requires little of the alkaloid to kill (by accident or design) the relative potency is not too relevant.

Link to comment
The range of Hemlock is the whole of Europe and Northern Asia , as ive mentioned previously , the closer to the Nile -the stronger the active principle of the plant.

 

When you say closer to the Nile, do you mean it is also located in the Nile?

Link to comment
The range of Hemlock is the whole of Europe and Northern Asia , as ive mentioned previously , the closer to the Nile -the stronger the active principle of the plant.

 

When you say closer to the Nile, do you mean it is also located in the Nile?

 

I will check my range maps , I dont recall seeing it in Karnak , but I dont see why it shouldnt be in Egypt. My remark concerns the general fertile potency of the Egyptian climate, all medicinal plants seem to have greater potency (and are attested so in the Ancient world) as one moves toward Egypt.Fresh herbs from Egypt were the best plants available to the Romans , but as Pliny says many journeymen could not identify the "real thing" versus the dried (and hence less effective) plant or rhizome.

Link to comment

Re nicotine. It is generally responsible for PAD, Peripheral Arterial Disease. Same symptoms you mentioned above.

 

I hear that a new study has taken garlic off of the menu for bad cholesterol.

Link to comment

I hear that a new study has taken garlic off of the menu for bad cholesterol.

Yeah & I bet that study was funded by the Pharmaceutical industry... :ph34r:

Yell it like it is bro!

Link to comment

Yell it like it is bro!

For what it's worth here are the offending articles: Archives of Internal Medicine - Garlic

 

The NPR story I heard yesterday on this mentioned that they were putting the raw garlic in with 'gourmet sandwiches' and the there was no dietary restriction on the people taking the suppliments.

 

So I ask, was this designed to fail? What if these people were on/maintaining a high cholesterol diet?

Link to comment

Once upon a time, when I would come back from my favorite Spanish restaurant (drunk), my Bride :wub: would ask me if I rubbed the stuff into my chest. I heard it on NPR also. I don't give a fig for the story. I'm still going to rub it on toast, bake heads of it and make sure it's on most of the things I eat. Jello?

Link to comment

Yell it like it is bro!

For what it's worth here are the offending articles: Archives of Internal Medicine - Garlic

 

The NPR story I heard yesterday on this mentioned that they were putting the raw garlic in with 'gourmet sandwiches' and the there was no dietary restriction on the people taking the suppliments.

 

So I ask, was this designed to fail? What if these people were on/maintaining a high cholesterol diet?

 

So no control group , or dietary prohibitions? Great science.

Link to comment
I hear that a new study has taken garlic off of the menu for bad cholesterol.

 

Bull pucky. Garlic and onions are a part of the culinary repetoire in nearly every gastronomic culture. They ain't bad...and there are few things in this world that rival roasted garlic spread over hot bread, with a wonderful fruity red to sip upon. Anyone who says otherwise needs to get away from the vampires. :ph34r:

Link to comment

Interestingly the "garlic question" has come out at just the time in the UK when it is now suggested that even the most banal of pain killers , asprin, paracetamol and (by far the worst) ibuprofen cause gross cardio damage. The ibuprofen is culpable in damaging the gut wall integrity, it is available over the counter but is included in many other medications. I wish to prophesy that it will be found to be a co-factor in alzheimers disease.

 

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml...7/npills127.xml

Link to comment
The ibuprofen is culpable in damaging the gut wall integrity, it is available over the counter but is included in many other medications.

 

I think all pain-killers are inherently evil if overused...and, sadly, many overuse them. I'm down to rarely having to take an Advil (ibuprofen), and instead switch to a potent potable of choice :ph34r: Better for you, I reckon, plus it makes life so much happier!

Link to comment
×
×
  • Create New...