Jump to content
UNRV Ancient Roman Empire Forums

caesar novus

Equites
  • Posts

    754
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    43

Everything posted by caesar novus

  1. Gosh, I have stayed in Desenzano and didn't even know about the villa. But otherwise it is quite dull, and I might even try Peschiera as one train stop. Not that it is better, but maybe works with the ferry schedule better to include one of the great lakeshore walks between Garda, Bardolino, and Lazise. You can get a lower lake ferry day pass, and online schedule to see if this is doable with Sirmione. Probably would need warm weather due to infrequent ferries in the cold. P.S. I think it was you that nudged me into visiting Palermo - what a great experience of mosaics, parks, and alleyways.
  2. How about some links to brainstorm and prioritize Roman site visits? Mideastern sites came to mind, and I couldn't seem to find the advertised Lebanese photos on Bryaxis Hecatee's Picasa site, so I got interesting results here (and a Syrian one): Have an android phone or tablet? Here are Roman apps (may have to login to gmail to display, then to download must open google market on your phone/tab). I have the search set to free apps only, but you can tweak it. For more touristy info change roman to rome. Note the Appian Way webcams and roman numeral calculators. https://market.android.com/search?q=roman&c=apps&price=1&safe=0&so=1&sort=1
  3. Well, I can help out using a new app called laptop-camera-pirate... just let me focus in closely on your genes. OK, it appears you are haplogroup I1 on wiki Try a click, I'm sure you will concur. One problem is that I believe these only check a single root of your family tree, eg. fathers fathers father or mothers mothers mother, because they just check cloned genes. And the markers are mutations, so if they only find a really old one your group will have since spread all over and differentiated. The above group isn't too old. You could be sneaky about finding these out via subterfuge or gift certificates. If your gift budget allows, you (possibly with siblings chipping in) could have your parents get dna tests, and then the whole family can get the info. Actually a female would have to have a male relative take the test for the y groups, which women don't carry. However males carry both types of genes. I took all tests with additional genes checked for health factors. Darn it, I just noticed my subgroup seems to be a mystery one - just flagged with an asterisk and nothing more on the web. I didn't find my health findings too believable because they don't match historical or present outlooks very well (but they did accurately predict physical characteristics like eye color etc).
  4. I'm sure I will repeat this course, I'm just sorry I only have access to the audio and not video portion. I don't think it's difficult at all - he seems to drill down to the heart of the matter and keeps you saying "Oh, that finally makes sense to me, when you tell it THAT way". The death mask origin of Roman portrait sculpture is kind of creepy, but must explain the typically deadpan (or at least unassuming) expression of the mouth and eyes. Such a contrast to the theatrical or pretentious norm, but I suppose it is just another form of affectation for which I project noble thoughts into.
  5. I think there already is an active archeo-looters infrastructure in Egypt that would be eyeing a chance to immediately leap from the shadows. Some museum employees probably have been approached by them over the years and a few figured now they can get away with what they couldn't before. I have seen reports from Israeli law enforcement tracking down local outlaw rings that hook up with sophisticated antiquity robbing-for-hire groups in Egypt. When I was Egypt long ago, the anti western side was hidden and more apparent was the opposite - sort of a solidarity with tourists as people who were less predatory than similarly wealthy residents. Their were obvious splits in society - flamboyant misbegotten wealth and crass treatment of minorities even in public. Every society has fractures, but what may be hard to relate to is Egypt's long term stagnation of hope for self betterment in terms of money or position. We may have Phd's taking up homeless lifestyles, but more as a slacker choice rather than an insurmountable fate. Folks in western China have hard, poor lives... but they can bear it due to anticipating relief coming as economic blessings move westward over the years.
  6. Thanks, although I had seen wiki I did find scraps of support for the TV claims in other googled up sources. From pbs.org: "Herodotus described the battle as 'the finest victory in all history known to me.' (Herod. Book 9)" but then is skeptical when Herod. claims the Persians outnumbered Greeks 17 to 1. Another source points out it was one of the only open land battles, where Persian archers and cavalry were in their element vs the Spartans not being able to project power. The Spartans were against a deadline since their water supply had been poisoned, so had to win or flee. Several sources say the strategic importance of victory was pretty decisive, but no one source seems to pull the various claims together so maybe they are controversial. Before this I thought the Spartans may have been overrated. So weird the way they were too late to Marathon due to their superstitious fetishes, and the Thermop* thing seemed more like grandstanding where there were ways to eventually bypass them by sea or thru the mountains. EDIT-> I also like how the Spartans used fake retreat in the topic battle - not just macho bashing about, if reports can be believed.
  7. Tv news showed somebody's mathematical model weighing degrees of valid grievances, youthful dissent, etc per country and came up with an ordered list ripe for popular overthrow as something like Tunisia, Egypt, Jordan, Yemen, and then Venezuela. If this is more orchestrated, we should eventually hear about it. I was surprised to see Hitler quoted as admitting in dinner conversation to being a copycat to Mussolini, somewhat like Egypt is to Tunisia. In Martin Bormann's "Hitlers Tabletalk", he quotes him as barely dreaming of success until he saw blackshirts succeed on the streets of Rome. I hope it is ok and interesting to paste a page in here which is a portion of the 1953 translation from the internet. It circles around back to the Roman empire.
  8. I was thinking of more along the lines of montage which was started under the soviets http://filmeditor.wordpress.com/2007/12/24/montage-theory/ but there is some new use that I have heard about but forgotten for TV documentaries. The end result is about 5% of the recording takes half my time because I have to keep freezing the 2 second archeo shots. A little sad to see Pompeii which is visibly falling apart compared to earlier visits. Same for Ostia Antica - the most famous mosaics are a shadow of what you may have seen a few years ago. I think it's strange how they sometimes let you trample fragile mosaics in Italy, but memorable anyway.
  9. Another bother was their depiction of well off Pompeii folks as condescendingly arrogant and theatrically flaunting their luxuries. How do they know the Romans weren't aspirational and savoring their special foods, etc like folks now at slow food fests for example?
  10. Well, partly the obvious highlight stories are done and avail for repeats (such as on military channel). Also history broadcasts in general seem to be falling off - the history channel is now mostly reality shows, just as the travel channel is now mostly cooking shows. They start with high ideals, then especially with higher HiDef production costs they have to pander to the all too common denominator.
  11. I saw a documentary that spun the battle of Plataea into sort of a gateway to western civilization. Was it one of the Spartans greatest contribution in allowing Athens to flower? Other sources seem to downplay it. They emphasized that the Spartans were technologically outclassed by opposing cavalry and had to develop a crazy jogging tactic for when they couldn't get advantage by terrain. As usual they were way outnumbered. It seemed almost more significant victory than thermop* which had to rely a lot on a sea battle; while Palataea left the Athenians free to shape much of the cultural rewards we know today. Furthermore it taught the west that some elements of the rather weird Spartan warrior culture would be needed to defend itself in future centuries?
  12. The food issue seems so needless - they should have very slowly reduced food subsidies so that local farmers could benefit and ramp up production before city dwellers felt much pain. Export bans raise internationally traded food costs dramatically. The US wastes massive farmland due to irrational but mandated biofuel production. The EU stifles production with genetic modified bans. Well, maybe this will be a painful birth of a more rational world
  13. Before I challenge that by the below quotes, some sentence padding here will make it more readible. So I will add to your anti-western theme in Egypt some internal fractures. There is bitter resentment of a kleptocracy class. The gypsies are treated brutally. Common folks are kept in poverty because they can't get enforceable property rights over their makeshift homes, etc. Hawass should be boycotted by all archeologists, and all escavation funding frozen. What may have started as revenge for a Unesco appointment has turned into an escalating shakedown of western museums because they have been so spinelessly aquiescent. Why? For combating looting?
  14. I liked the other episodes more than Pompeii one. In all cases, it is fun to freeze frame and back up for views of the archeology which somehow seems more clear on HiDef than real life. The best scenes just appear for a second or two - there is some name for that annoying process that makes impressions by bombarding you with machine gun scene changes. Pompeii episode had one interesting insight explaining the poses of the bodies being artificial. The fetal positions were not from gasping for breath, but happened after death as the muscles were cooked before rigor mortis set in. The big muscles contract more than opposing smaller ones, so give a "pugilistic" stance including clenched fists like a boxer. I will have to check that next time I visit a cannibal BBQ. One aspect annoyed me. There was heavy condemnation of it as a slave market, and when finding a skeleton in shackles with no signs of hard labor (joints) they decided he wasn't a murderer but one of hundreds of slaves left cruelly to die in their supposed massive caged building. They did mention one successful ex slave, but not all the nuances about slaves often being more like indentured servants. Basically it echoed a UC Berkeley online course on Romans which implied it was an utterly corrupt diversion on path of civilization because it was non-Marxist.
  15. I could never get the slightest support in this forum for saying Roman sculpture was uniquely visceral vs a kind of mannered stiffness of the Greek. But in a fascinating lecture series "Greece and Rome: An Integrated History of the Ancient Mediterranean" Prof. Robert Garland backs me up in saying Roman portrait sculpture was uniquely based the tradition of death masks rather than idealization. Even if they were done by Greek artists, they had to change to the Roman warts and all depiction. Not just a fashion, but could have real purpose in identifying a VIP when seen live. http://www.teach12.com/tgc/courses/course_detail.aspx?cid=3300 I love Roman sculpture, and almost everything that this course attributes to the Romans, whether it was different from the Greeks or borrowed from them. SPQR
  16. I was practically hounded out of this forum by daring to suggest Zahi Hawass had no right to bully and manipulate the west in returning large amounts of egyptian artifacts - and that politi-correct appeasers of the west shouldn't allow world treasures to be consolidated to home locations with all the attendant risks. Now that ghastly regular of TV documentaries is bemoaning how, although looters have been driven out of the museum in a trail of destruction, the burning building next door threatens to crush the museum. The mobs may be protective of the museum but they are targeting adjacent areas with collateral damage a possiblity. http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2011/01/29/world/middleeast/AP-ML-Egypt-Protest-Antiquities.html?_r=1&ref=news I have been to a lot of less developed countries, but few seemed such a civil powderkeg as Egypt. They have bottled up resentments that were visceral on the streets even years ago, and seem too pervasive to go away with a simple change of a leader or two. What a place to put all your artifacts in one basket. It isn't just an Egyptian thing. It was looney to place a large proportion of Dali's paintings beachside in hurricane alley. St Petersburg FL has just spent umpteen millions to relocate them to a bunker museum. Yecch what a waste, but at least it's more responsible than consolidating them all in, say a Basque liberation army stronghold closer to the artists home.
  17. First of all, it's the hypocrisy by gov't I point to - switching their story in order to ride the coattails of dufus populism and further inflame the mob. I wasn't promoting de-regulation as an ideology; note I pointed to over regulation as "A" cause. as well as under regulation. As for the oil spill, I haven't followed details too closely since I've been on the road a lot with spotty access to media. So I'll address your bigger picture allusion. Yes, there is dysfunction based on the need for politicians to fund really expensive campaigns. Corporations cynically threw money primarily at their ideological enemies in 2008 because they were ahead in the polls. So now they have leverage over their paid-for politicians. Granted this is way out of control, but it isn't entirely evil. Corporations can be the only advocates for consumer issues that are too small or technical for particular individuals to get excited about, but are important en masse when it can make a wide customer base happier. Under ideal competition corporations bring some balance of power as intermediaries between consumers and suppliers of labor/capital/material. An exception to this is powerful labor unions, which answer to no consumer or provider of capital or managers. The fact that their political contributions could leverage gov't to subvert GM bondholders and centuries of contract law about bondholder rights shows the severe dysfunction and will dampen needed lending going forward. Where I live this is taken even further where management (school principals) are forced to be members of teacher unions, so there is no balance of power or intermediary covering parent requirements at all. The schools are run purely to please complacent workers and are among the worst in the developed world. Unlike corporations, those teacher unions are unaccountable to any consumer of their service since their political contribution power mostly trumps diffuse voter dissatisfication. Now to circle back to my original theme of 2 faced populism, the reason this dysfunction works in the face of supposed democracy isn't entirely the misuse of money... but of the voters letting themselves be taken in by opportunistic populist demogoguery. And that is most notable when politicians switch sides on an issue and feign outrage at what they have supported on record. I guess this thread was meant to alert people to not be taken in, or else the next regulation will be based on the exaggerated populist perception rather than addressing real problems with balance. It was apparent in a small way with the oil spill, but in a huge way with the mortgage crises. All stripes of politicians used to be wildly pushing regulations promoting gov't approved house loans for deadbeats - I think the normally very responsible Barney Frank was the most recent caught pretending he wasn't on the wrong side of the issue http://www.zerohedge.com/article/barney-fr...rrassed-about-f . Also might make a similar case about of the whys of Iraq invasion. All sort of invasion critic politicians voted FOR a multi point reasons for invasion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Resolut...t_Iraq#Contents but later pretended only the troubled "weapons of mass destruction" one really counted.
  18. Germany was highlighted to support my theme of OVER regulation as a cause of the crises as opposed to just UNDER regulation, if I remember an article of Economist magazine correctly. They said the Landesbanks (a special kind of German bank) profits and thus survival were in a death grip from over conservative regulations well before the crisis. They went to AIG out of desperation to survive supposedly, whereas the other banks went to them out of greed. Well I thank you for being supportive in general, but I should admit I pushed the theme a bit far and folks are probably being too polite to point out a few holes in it. Interesting to consider the less reported angles anyway.
  19. Originally the temperate US government response to the oil spill gave hope that due process could identify the root of the problem, and that innovation could march on using those lessons. But now the populist mob has forced them into a frenzy of duplicitous self righteous rhetoric and threats of irrational damaging legislation. Is it any surprise that the high risk drilling was promoted by subsidies? The Clinton administration passed the "Deep Water Royalty Relief Act" and failed to deactivate it when scheduled. Congress sweetened it up during Bush administration according to http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Why-Was-BP-D...813326.html?x=0 . How does the mainstream press let the lawmakers get away with this hypocrisy, even back on the financial crisis? The Clinton administration decided that gov't backed mortgages were being refused due to predjuice rather than the facts that show individuals had hopeless credit histories. So they force loans to be made to every victimology category that predictably blow up en mass later. http://finance.yahoo.com/tech-ticker/fanni...ftt_503592.html Same case internationally. Germany gov't wears the mask of regulated responsibility, but their overregulation of landesbanks (sp?) left them suicidally unprofitable. For survival they tapped into looney schemes from US AIG, which blew up with the US mortgage market (caused by not only US but Chinese gov't which flooded US with lending rather than spending). What bugs me is the US gov't bailed out AIG and thus Germany (85 billiion IIRC) rather than a scheme already on the table that shared the pain at least a bit with the greedy customers (like German banks). Lost the link on this, but the hypocrisy just goes on and voters and press let gov't get away with it.
  20. That's exactly the attitude that can stifle enlightment on the issue, and the reason for this thread. People have been afraid to describe advances of civilization in those cases where a reprehensible person was responsible, and the story becomes lost. Freeways were just an obvious thing that came from the sky. Every major Christian domed church looks like Nero's octagon room throughout 2000 years only due to habit... and just forget Nero's brilliant architects Severus and Celer because a bad person happened to approve of their work. It would be a shame to tiptoe around and be hesitant to describe real history as it was due to self censorship. This thread has maintained the contempt for the bad guys with adjectives like demonic, notorious, tyrants, and so on. The bad can do many good things which don't at all lessen the seriousness of their crimes or depravity.
  21. I remember a lecture about the 5 good emperors where excuses were made for their bad behavior, and how "good" was used in very narrow realpolitik terms of the time. Except for Marcus Aurelius, maybe their goodness was partly just an inability to father a son and having to name a successor based on merit rather than their demon seed. Actually I wasn't thinking about whether behavior was mixed good and bad. I was thinking the birth of lasting cultural icons that were steppingstones to where we are today... but coming from an unsavory source. I forget the details, but I believe Nero's palace octagon room was a huge step towards later domed civic and church buildings. Caligula is sometimes credited with laying the engineering groundworks for the integration of Britain into Roman civilization. Hitler's freeways amazed Eisenhower who pushed for them in the US and they later transformed the world for better or worse. Hitler's unprecedented campaigning by air travel during his brief democratic phase allowed voters in vast countries (later elsewhere) live exposure to candidates.
  22. I remember being confused about some advances of architecture and painting style happening under Nero's direction, then realized being a tyrant doesn't mean you say no to every good idea. History forgets, for instance, that Hitler brought about innovative freeway systems, political campaigning by airplane visits, and green-ness in the form of his vegetarianism. I suspect that even Caligula did some good, but can't remember. Would anyone care to list some good contributions whose origin is forgotten due to the monstrous reputation of the emperor?
  23. Well, your itinerary is so jammed, maybe skip Burano in favor of Roman Sirmione and Venice Navy: . .
  24. Also see supercute Burano, a sort of colorful toy Venice, on the same vaporetti route (don't use the expensive excursion boats near St. Marks, but the regular vaporetti from the backside of Castello). Maybe do this on a day pass, and do other scenic routes the same day around the imain island and main canal. The price of vaporetti has gone up so much I might just walk on other days, which is easy if you avoid the crunch between train station - rialto - San Marco (use the academia bridge and pleasant connecting backstreets instead). Visit fishtail beyond St Marco (has spacious parks and a wide boulevard where Napoleon filled in a canal). The gateway to this has the must-see NAVAL MUSEUM which documents the Roman pleasure barges of Lake Nemi and their excavation and demise. You should get in at 9am opening time, because you may not get thru it's 5 stories by the mid day closing time otherwise. Fascinating displays, such as the Viking incursions of Italy (sacked the wrong city they thought was Rome), ancient cannons, WW2 almost-suicide boats (had ejection seats for just before collision), ship artillery computers as big as a room, the surprising secrets of asymmetrical gondola design, seashells etc etc. Skip Milano.
  25. I should thank you for your Pozzuoli report. I was taking a rest day on Ischia, then realized I was a short ferry hop from Pozzuoli. I didn't have maps or anything more than memories of your photo journal, but managed to savor the arena and seripede roman remains just fine. You are going to only pass by the sprawling Roman ruins at Sirmione on stunning Lake Garda? Well, maybe you have already been there. But I wouldn't miss an opportunity of stopping off the B. to V. train at Desenzano and ferry or bus to Sirmione. Or even savor the lake a bit more with the express bus from Brescia to Salo or Gardone Riviera, then ferry to Garda, then you can walk the shoreline thru Bardolino and Lazise, then ferry hop to Sirmone (can bus to Verona from most of these last places). All doable even with your luggage in a backpack.
×
×
  • Create New...