I agree 100%. To be blunt, this idea really, really blows. It would suck all the fun out of UNRV. I am not an academic, I am an enthusiastic amatuer. This proposed new system effectively rules me out of all future debates, period (I have a few dozen Rome books, but even if I had the time to stack them up beside my computer and source all of my posts, I would certainly not enjoy thumbing through them every time I wished to contribute to a thread). It may be ok for those of us that have an encyclopedic memory, or are deep into the subject every day of their lives (lecturers and what have you), but it's not good for the rest of us.
To me this smacks of elitism.
I come here for fun and discussion. I simply don't have time for all the academic flummery.
If this becomes the norm, it will be a case of "goodnight" from me.
(quoted again for truth).
And then there's the logistics to think about.
Edit - just read that this will be a separate forum. Ok, I guess if people want this then let them have it. I see no problems with the current system.